Unmasking Atlantis: Dream or Destiny?

Read Text C, and then answer Questions 15 to Question 19 on the question paper.
Unmasking Atlantis: Dream or Destiny?
The text below is about exploring the concept of underwater cities by focusing on the technological and ecological dimensions of ‘Atlantis’.
1
Imagining life far below the oceans, where sunlight barely penetrates, excites scientists, architects, and dreamers alike. A topic that has captured the intrigue of many is the idea of underwater cities. Among these, Atlantis stands out as the quintessential symbol of submerged settlements. While rooted in mythical lore, Atlantis evokes questions about the real possibility of engineering such habitats. Can we create cities beneath the waves? And what would it take to make them viable—scientifically, environmentally, and technologically?
2
Advances in marine engineering have made underwater living an increasingly plausible reality. The 21st century has witnessed innovations such as undersea hotels and temporary research stations. These small-scale endeavours have tested modular structures and the use of materials like transparent acrylics capable of withstanding immense water pressure. However, scaling these experiments for permanent habitation presents enormous challenges. Designers must account for oxygen supplies, stable energy sources, and waste management—all crucial components of self-sufficient underwater systems.
3
Biodiversity often emerges as both a hazard and an opportunity for underwater urbanisation. Marine ecosystems are governed by delicate balances. Constructing a giant city underwater may profoundly disturb such balance, displacing aquatic creatures or unintentionally introducing pollutants. However, the reverse argument spotlights underwater cities as sanctuaries—places where overfished animals could regenerate, with human activities monitored collaboratively with automated drones and AI. This multifaceted impact remains a primary source of debate within environmental circles.
4
The Atlantis analogy often extends beyond fantasy due to its cultural significance. Some see it not merely as an underwater haven but as an advanced society that may have harnessed the power of the oceans. Ancient accounts, though not verified, inspire architects and thinkers pondering underwater power generation fields, such as tidal turbines, to keep an entire submerged ecosystem running. Successfully incorporating renewable energy on this scale could serve as a model for energy sustainability across the globe.
5
Then there are the psychological and social questions to consider. Would humanity adapt to isolated aquatic environments even with high-speed communication technologies? Living beneath the waves would mean grappling with long periods without natural sunlight. Experts suggest that structural designs featuring virtual reality displays simulating skies and landscapes might alleviate stress. Additionally, cultivating a self-contained community with sociocultural engagement—libraries, theatres, underwater farming—might logically accompany such settlements.
6
Finally, critics point out an often-overlooked reality: creating underwater cities might detract from efforts to save ecosystems already above water. Is it viable to build new environments when so much effort is still needed to halt rising seas, deforestation, and pollution? Supporters argue, however, that such projects might act as laboratories to test resilience under extreme environments, paving the way for both terrestrial and extraterrestrial colonisation. The potential gains in technology, ecological management, and human adaptability could outweigh the concerns of misdirected funds.
7
Ultimately, the dreams of Atlantis challenge people to create a balance between feasibility and ecological stewardship. Whether viewed as science fiction or an inevitable leap in human innovation, underwater cities offer a fascinating template for reflecting on how far technology and humanity can venture. The world beneath the sea remains as alluring yet as complex as the stars above—perhaps promising Atlantis is truly the lost treasure waiting to be rediscovered.

Question 15

Read the text and match the paragraphs with the appropriate headings. Write the correct letter (A-G). The first one has been done for you. There is one other letter you will not need to use.

[5 Marks]
Headings:

  • A: Technological barriers of underwater living
  • B: Exploring the cultural myths surrounding Atlantis
  • C: Biodiversity concerns and opportunities
  • D: Mental and emotional adaptations
  • E: Practical innovations in marine engineering
  • F: Potential clashes with current environmental restoration efforts
  • G: Integration of renewable energy underwater

Text Paragraphs:

  • Paragraph 1: B: Exploring the cultural myths surrounding Atlantis
  • Paragraph 2: …..
  • Paragraph 3: …..
  • Paragraph 4: …..
  • Paragraph 5: …..
  • Paragraph 6: …..

Question 16

From Paragraph 1, name two challenges that need to be addressed for underwater cities to become a reality.

[2 Mark]

  • (i)………………………
  • (ii)………………………

Question 17

According to Paragraph 3, what are the two differing viewpoints on the environmental impact of underwater cities?

[2 Mark]
  • (i) One viewpoint ………………………
  • (ii) Another viewpoint ………………………

Question 18

From paragraph 4, what does the writer mean by describing Atlantis as ‘an advanced society that may have harnessed the power of the oceans'?

[1 Mark]

Question 19

Summarise the implications and challenges of constructing underwater cities as discussed in Paragraphs 3 to 6 of the text. Write your summary in no more than 80 words.

[15 Marks]
Word Count: 0